Différences entre les versions de « Discussion utilisateur:Interwicket »

→‎Interwicket and typographic apostrophe : is the broken no-link-to-redirects "policy"
(→‎Interwicket and typographic apostrophe : is the broken no-link-to-redirects "policy")
Hi, I see Interwicket removed link of [[comme d’habitude]] (see [http://fr.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=comme_d%E2%80%99habitude&diff=5458740&oldid=5456850 here]). It removes it because english article uses non typographic apostrophe whereas french article use typographic apostrophe. Can you correct it ? [[User:Pamputt|Pamputt]] <sup><small> &#91;[[User Talk:Pamputt|Discuter]]&#93;</small></sup> 3 avril 2009 à 08:05 (UTC)
:Aren't we the only Wiktionary to use that? Also, is there one on a QWERTY keyboard, as I have to [[copier-coller|copy and paste]] one every time I need one. [[Utilisateur:Mglovesfun|Mglovesfun]] 3 avril 2009 à 09:40 (UTC)
 
:: Yes, this is the only wikt to use it. (English) QWERTY keyboards only have ' (and, amusingly, `) but not &#x2019;. It seems very odd to me to use RIGHT SINGLE QUOTATION MARK for an apostrophe... (Yes, in rendering/typesetting. But in ''content''? ;-)
 
:: See [[:en:User:Interwicket/Redirects]] for a discussion of this and many other issues. The English wikt links to redirects, but here the default is as it was, to not link to redirects, however useful. (Gerard was adamant that linking to them was somehow wrong (?), and unilaterally imposed that attitude on all the wikts while running RobotGMwikt.) There are quite a few cases of differing conventions between wikts; it isn't possible to compensate in code, it would involve a large and endlessly growing series of exceptions and special cases. (;-)
 
:: Also by using the redirects the local convention for any given entry can simple be changed around at will.
 
:: Note that the entry in the en.wikt [[:en:comme d'habitude]], which does link to redirects, has an iwiki that properly arrives at the entry here.
 
:: If you add a link to the redirect on the English wikt, Interwicket will not remove it, but the other interwiki bots will. (Which is why they are prohibited from running on the en.wikt, so as not to remove the links to fr.wikt redirects, etc, etc) [[Utilisateur:Robert Ullmann|Robert Ullmann]] 3 avril 2009 à 12:09 (UTC)
46

modifications